Home > Confectionery Supplies and Packaging > Plastic Cupcake Picks, Toppers and Candles

Unique Cake Toppers for Your Special Event

At Sweet Treat Supply, we offer the most unique cake and cupcake decorating supplies for all the special events in your life. Whether you are throwing a baby shower for a best friend, a graduation party for a child, or a holiday party for the neighborhood, be sure you have a unique cake, tailored to your specific party needs. For baby shower cupcake toppers, try our baby rattle cupcake picks or our baby blocks cupcake picks. An appropriate summer party cupcake pick might be our lemon & orange or hotdog on a bun picks. With so many plastic cupcake toppers to choose from, there’s sure to be something for your special occasion.

Graduation Cake Toppers

When it comes to celebrating a holiday or graduation, it’s important to have everything just perfect. As the host of a party, you want to coordinate everything from the tablecloth and paper goods to the balloons and party favors. Graduation cake toppers that coordinate with everything will make a graduation party that much more meaningful as well. At Sweet Treat Supply, we have just what you need to make your graduation or other celebration the most perfectly put together event. Order today for free shipping on every order of $100 or more!

Sort By:
Page of 2
Baby Rattle Cupcake Picks Plastic Pumpkins Cake Topper Ears of Corn Cupcake Picks
1-1/2" Baby Rattle Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
6 in stock!
1-1/2" Plastic Pumpkin Cake Topper - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
3 in stock!
2" Ears Of Corn Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
1 in stock!
Fruit and Veggies Cupcake Picks Grape and Apple Cupcake Picks Lemon & Orange Cupcake Picks
2" Fruit & Veggies Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
4 in stock!
2" Grape & Apple Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
6 in stock!
2" Lemon & Orange Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
6 in stock!
Autumn Leaves Cupcake Picks Hotdog on a Bun Cupcake Picks Gold Metallic Candles - 10 Pack
2-1/2" Autumn Leaves Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
9 in stock!
2-1/2" Hotdog On Bun Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
2 in stock!
2-1/4" Metallic Gold Candles - 10 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.89
52 in stock!
Silver Metallic Candles - 10 Pack 3" Baseball Players Cake Topper - 4 Pack 3" Batmanâ„¢ Spoon Cake Topper
2-1/4" Metallic Silver Candles - 10 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.89
54 in stock!
3" Baseball Players Cake Topper - 4 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
4 in stock!
3" Batman™ Spoon Cake Topper (BAT-70)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
6 in stock!
Firecracker 4th of July Cupcake Picks 3" Jack O Lantern Basket Decoration 4" Blue Congratulations Script Topper
3" Firecracker 4Th Of July Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
25 in stock!
3" Jack O Lantern Decoration
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
1 in stock!
4" Blue Congratulations Script Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.25
20 in stock!
4" Green Congratulations Script Topper 4" Pink Congratulations Script Topper 4X4 Pickup Truck Cake Topper
4" Green Congratulations Script Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.25
19 in stock!
4" Pink Congratulations Script Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.25
10 in stock!
4X4 Pickup Truck Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
19 in stock!
6" Brunette  Doll Pick Cake Decoration 8" Jointed Skeleton Decoration Airplane Cupcake Picks
6" Brunette Doll Pick Cake Decoration
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.49
2 in stock!
8" Jointed Skeleton Vintage Decoration - Top Hat Missing
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.49
1 in stock!
Airplane Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
1 in stock!
Assorted Baby Themed Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack Baby Blocks Cupcake Toppers - 4 Pack Baby Booties Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Assorted Baby Themed Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
4 in stock!
Baby Blocks Cupcake Toppers - 4 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
6 in stock!
Baby Booties Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
14 in stock!
Baby Boy Blue Cupcake Picks Baby Buggy Picks Mold Baseball Cupcake Picks
Baby Boy Blue Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
9 in stock!
Baby Buggy Picks Chocolate Mold (90-P8027)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
36 in stock!
Baseball Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
16 in stock!
Baseball Party Candle Holders with Candles Basketball Rings Or Cupcake Toppers - 6 Pack Beer Can Cupcake Picks
Baseball Party Candle Holders with Candles - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
5 in stock!
Basketball Rings Or Cupcake Toppers - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
5 in stock!
Beer Can Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
4 in stock!
Best Wishes Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Black Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper Black Graduate Mortar Board Cap Cake Topper
Best Wishes Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
21 in stock!
Black Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
2 in stock!
Black Graduation Cap Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
5 in stock!
Black Graduation Cap Layon Blonde Graduate Boy Cake Topper Blue "Joy" Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Black Graduation Cap Layon
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
6 in stock!
Blonde Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
16 in stock!
Blue "Joy" Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
5 in stock!
Blue Doves Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Blue Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper Boy Graduate Black Outline Decal - 6 Pack
Blue Doves Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.59
6 in stock!
Blue Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
2 in stock!
Boy Graduate Black Outline Decal - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
20 in stock!
Boy Praying at Altar Cake Topper Brunette Graduate Boy Cake Topper Camouflage Chunky Candles - 4 Pack
Boy Praying At Altar Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
4 in stock!
Brunette Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
19 in stock!
Camouflage Chunky Candles - 4 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
(Out of Stock)
Champagne Party Candle Holders with Candles - 4 Pack Chick in Egg Cupcake Picks - 12 Count Christmas Assortment Chocopick Mold
Champagne Party Candle Holders with Candles - 4 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
2 in stock!
Chick in Egg Cupcake Picks - 12 Count
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
1 in stock!
Chocopick Christmas Assortment Mold (90-P4109)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
6 in stock!
Chocopicks Jack O Lantern Chocolate Mold halloween fall autumn pumpkin P3001 Chocopicks Sign Chocolate Mold cupcake topper P9001 Wedding Bells Chocopicks Mold
Chocopick Jack O Lantern Chocolate Mold (90-P3001)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
9 in stock!
Chocopick Sign Chocolate Mold (90-P9001)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
8 in stock!
Chocopicks Wedding Bells Chocolate Mold (90-P8025)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
45 in stock!
Clown Head Shaped Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Coconut Drink Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Cornucopia Cupcake Picks
Clown Head Shaped Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.49
15 in stock!
Coconut Drink Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
1 in stock!
Cornucopia Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
3 in stock!
Dark Blue Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper Engagement Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Ethnic White Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper
Dark Blue Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
15 in stock!
Engagement Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
7 in stock!
Ethnic White Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
7 in stock!
Fairly Odd Parents Candle Fairy Girls Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack Fashionable Chic Cupcake Picks
Fairly Odd Parents Candle (2811-6262)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
2 in stock!
Fairy Girls Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
1 in stock!
Fashionable Chic Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
15 in stock!
Felicidades Graduate Picks - 6 Pack Flip Flop Sandals Cupcake Picks Flower Bouquet Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Felicidades Graduate Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
9 in stock!
Flip Flop Sandals Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
24 in stock!
Flower Bouquet Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
8 in stock!
Football Helmet Cake Toppers Football Helmet Cake Toppers - Red/Black Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers -  Aqua Blue - 6 Pack
Football Helmet Cake Topper - Red/Blue - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
2 in stock!
Football Helmet Cake Toppers - Red - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
8 in stock!
Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers - Aqua Blue - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
8 in stock!
Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers - Blue/Black Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers - Gold Football Helmet Cake Toppers
Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers - Blue - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
9 in stock!
Football Helmet Cupcake Toppers - Gold - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
14 in stock!
Football Helmet Vintage Cake Topper - Gold/Green - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
1 in stock!
Football Shaped Cupcake Icing Decorations - 9 Pack Ghost Rings Or Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack Girl and Boy Couple Strolling
Football Shaped Cupcake Icing Decorations - 9 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.19
(Out of Stock)
Ghost Rings Or Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
9 in stock!
Girl And Boy Couple Cake Topper - Wilton 1301-552
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $7.99
7 in stock!
Female Graduate Black Outline Decal Vintage Wilton Girl with Umbrella Topper Gold Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Girl Graduate Black Outline Decal - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
22 in stock!
Girl With Umbrella Topper - Wilton 1316-305
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $7.99
4 in stock!
Gold Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
8 in stock!
Gold Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper Golden Cross Cupcake Pick Green Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Gold Gown Graduate Girl Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
16 in stock!
Golden Cross Cupcake Pick
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.49
22 in stock!
Green Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
5 in stock!
Guitar Cake Cupcake Toppers Halloween Variety Pack of Rings - 6 Pack Happy Holidays Cake Topper
Guitar Cupcake Toppers - 6 Pack - EC-4
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
20 in stock!
Halloween Variety Rings - 7 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
(Out of Stock)
Happy Holidays Cake Topper - 2 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.59
18 in stock!
Happy Holidays Cake Topper Happy New Years Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Hello Kitty Candle
Happy Holidays Cake Topper - 2 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.59
30 in stock!
Happy New Years Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
13 in stock!
Hello Kitty Candle (HK-15)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
1 in stock!
Hello KItty® Spoon Cake Topper (HK-40) St. Patrick's Day Cupcake Picks Language of Love Wedding Cake Topper
Hello KItty® Spoon Cake Topper (HK-40)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
5 in stock!
Irish St. Patrick's Day Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
11 in stock!
Language of Love Wedding Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $39.99
1 in stock!
Mummy Set Cake Topper - 6 Piece Set Mustache Icing Decorations Number 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Cake Topper Picks Mold
Mummy Set Cake Topper - 6 Piece Set
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
5 in stock!
Mustache Edible Icing Decorations - Wilton 710-0229
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.19
7 in stock!
Numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 Cake Toppers Chocolate Mold - LPL037
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
6 in stock!
Numbers 6, 7, 8, 9, 0 Topper Picks Mold Wilton Paper Lantern Candle and Cake Decoration Peace on Earth Cake Topper
Numbers 6, 7, 8, 9, 0 Cake Topper Chocolate Mold - LPL038
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
6 in stock!
Paper Lantern Candle Set - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.99
4 in stock!
Peace On Earth Cake Plaque - 2 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.59
31 in stock!
Pencil & Pad Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Pineapple Paper Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Pink Parasol Cake Topper
Pencil & Pad Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
7 in stock!
Pineapple Paper Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
10 in stock!
Pink Parasol Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
9 in stock!
Plastic Butterfly Cake Topper - 6 Pack Poinsettia Picks Princess Ring Or Cupcake Topper - 6 Pack
Plastic Butterfly Cake Topper - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
2 in stock!
Poinsettia Pick - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
11 in stock!
Princess Ring Or Cupcake Topper - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
6 in stock!
Purple Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper Purple Graduate Mortar Board Cap Cake Topper Red Graduate Mortar Board Cap Cake Topper
Purple Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
10 in stock!
Purple Graduation Cap Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
44 in stock!
Red Graduation Cap Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
22 in stock!
Red Noel Christmas Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Rocking Horse Blue Cupcake Pick - 6 Pack Ruler & Pad Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Red Noel Christmas Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
3 in stock!
Rocking Horse Blue Cupcake Pick - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
3 in stock!
Ruler & Pad Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
7 in stock!
Santa Face Pop Top Set Sea Creatures Puffy Picks - 6 Pack Seashore Jewel Puffy Picks - 6 Pack
Santa Face Pop Top Set Cake Decoration
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
7 in stock!
Sea Creatures Puffy Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
13 in stock!
Seashore Jewel Puffy Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
24 in stock!
Season's Greetings Cake Topper Shiny Easter Egg Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack Small Gift Boxes Decoration
Season'S Greetings Cake Topper - 2 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.59
30 in stock!
Shiny Easter Egg Cupcake Picks - 12 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
4 in stock!
Small Gift Packages Decorations - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
4 in stock!
Soccer Ball Rings Or Cupcake Toppers- 6 Pack Star of David Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Steam Train Engine Cupcake Picks
Soccer Ball Rings Or Cupcake Toppers- 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
6 in stock!
Star of David Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
24 in stock!
Steam Train Engine Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
10 in stock!
Teen Doll Pick Blonde Cake Decoration USA Top Hat Cupcake Picks Be My Valentine Cupcake Picks
Teen Doll Pick Blonde Cake Decoration (2815-102)
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $3.49
3 in stock!
USA Top Hat Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
3 in stock!
Vintage Be My Valentine Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
1 in stock!
LOVE with Children Cake Topper Watermelon Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack Dual Wedding Bells Picks
Vintage Love With Children Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
23 in stock!
Watermelon Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
7 in stock!
Wedding Bells Cupcake Picks - 6 Pack
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $0.99
5 in stock!
White Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper White Graduate Mortar Board Cap Cake Topper Skateboard Stunt Rider
White Gown Graduate Boy Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
7 in stock!
White Graduation Cap Cake Topper
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $1.99
45 in stock!
Wilton 5" Skateboard Stunt Rider - Wilton 1821-5024
Usually Ships in 24 Hours
Regular Price: $2.99
5 in stock!
   
 

Sweet Treat Supply

Your Candy Making and Cake Decorating Superstore!